> ȸ¿ø¸¶´ç >
¹Ì·¡±³À°ÀÚÀ¯Æ÷·³ ±¹Á¤°¨»ç ¸ð´ÏÅ͸µ
Impeachment, then, is a tool that the legislative
2019-12-20
3478-3478-3478
If Trump has broken a
´ä·Ê¶±
=´ä·Êǰ ´ä·Ê¶± Çà»ç¶± ±îÄ¡¶±
constitutional law of the US and he is sent to the Senate for trial, but the Republicans control the Senate where it's reported that he'd be unlikely to be removed from office, how is that justice if he had actually committed a crime? - Paul Perhaps justice has nothing to do with it. The men who wrote
¼´ë¹®±¸Æ÷ÀåÀÌ»ç
and approved the US constitution in 1787 made a conscious decision to make the impeachment and removal process a political one. They put politicians in charge of it, after all. The American system of government was designed to set equal
¿ë°µ¿¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
branches of government - the executive, the legislative and the judiciary - in constant
Àá½Ç¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
tension. It was a way, they theorised, to prevent government tyranny. Impeachment, then, is a tool that the legislative
ÀåÀ§µ¿¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
branch has to protect its
µ¿´ë¹®¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
prerogatives and keep the president accountable. Whether it's also a tool for "justice" is open for debate. Should the Senate vote in line with political allegiance, as expected, or should they
È«Äá¸íǰÁö°©
=È«Äá¸íǰÁö°©
vote as independent jurors? - Will Barnett, Bristol, 26
X
constitutional law of the US and he is sent to the Senate for trial, but the Republicans control the Senate where it's reported that he'd be unlikely to be removed from office, how is that justice if he had actually committed a crime? - Paul Perhaps justice has nothing to do with it. The men who wrote ¼´ë¹®±¸Æ÷ÀåÀÌ»ç
and approved the US constitution in 1787 made a conscious decision to make the impeachment and removal process a political one. They put politicians in charge of it, after all. The American system of government was designed to set equal ¿ë°µ¿¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
branches of government - the executive, the legislative and the judiciary - in constant Àá½Ç¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
tension. It was a way, they theorised, to prevent government tyranny. Impeachment, then, is a tool that the legislative ÀåÀ§µ¿¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
branch has to protect its µ¿´ë¹®¿ë´ÞÀÌ»ç
prerogatives and keep the president accountable. Whether it's also a tool for "justice" is open for debate. Should the Senate vote in line with political allegiance, as expected, or should they È«Äá¸íǰÁö°©=È«Äá¸íǰÁö°©
vote as independent jurors? - Will Barnett, Bristol, 26